In 1936, celebrated American author F. Scott Fitzgerald made a list. He’d hit a big rough patch in a life full of rough patches, drinking too much and living in a hotel in Asheville, North Carolina to be close to his institutionalized, schizophrenic wife. After an alleged suicide attempt and a nasty shoulder injury, Fitzgerald hired a nurse named Dorothy Richardson to care for him.
As they got to know one another, Fitzgerald made her a list of books he thought she ought to read. The list includes some William Faulkner, Theodore Drieser, Leo Tolstoy, John Keats, and such—twenty-two works in all. Some I’ve read. Most, I admit, I haven’t.
But that’s okay, because F. Scott Fitzgerald didn’t make the list for me, and suggesting a book for people can seem like kind of an intimate thing. You’re asking them to pour hours of their time into an experience, one they will engage with during their personal downtime, maybe while they’re drowsy and wearing their pajamas, or lounging on the beach in a swimsuit they feel just a little bit too chubby to wear, or nervously waiting for their loved one’s surgical procedure to end and hoping no waiting room strangers will strike up a conversation.
You hope they’ll like it. You hope they won’t think you have no taste, or that you think they have no taste, or that they think you chose this book because it says something to you about them or that you think it says something about yourself and you’re hoping they’ll notice. It’s a little like offering up a piece of your soul.
But just once in a while it works out. You read a book and it makes you think of one of your friends, who then absolutely loves the book you recommended and is touched that you just seem to get her, at which point she asks you for another recommendation and the stakes become higher.
And that’s why I am especially grateful to have so many wonderful friends who are willing to put themselves out there. Earlier this week, I was thinking about what books I wanted to pick up to finish out my year in reading. Looking over my To-Be-Read list on Goodreads, I realized I had fallen behind a little on my pace if I was going to meet my year-end goal. Most of the list in front of me included books that were either going to be hard to get hold of quickly or were probably not going to be quick reads.
I asked Facebook for suggestions of light, fast reads. And boy did my friends come through! As of right now, about four days later, my plea has received eighty responses. And that doesn’t count my librarian friend who texted me directly with several titles.
I do find it pretty gratifying that a lot of the suggestions are books I’ve read or that were already titles I’d come across and wanted to read, an indication that my friends and I probably know each other fairly well. But I’m even more impressed that so many people took the risk and put their opinions out there.
I read broadly, and with few exceptions, I’ll give anything a try. Maybe then, I’m not a terribly intimidating person to offer book suggestions. I also definitely recognize that the reading experience is largely an individual one and that I myself might view a book differently were I to read it today or a month from now, so I’m never going to judge a person based on the recommendations he makes.
And I’m not assuming that the list of books offered to me are the essential books that should be read by everyone, which Fitzgerald may have implied to his nurse, mainly by virtue, I think, of who he happened to be and also because he was probably a little drunk. It should be noted that there are some fairly universally accepted greats missing from his list, including Shakespeare. Any high school English teacher would probably be pretty quick to point out that particular oversight.
So, dear blogosphere, it’s your turn. What should I read? I can’t guarantee I’ll follow every suggestion, and I’m sure I won’t get to them all by the end of the year, but I promise I won’t think less of you for throwing it out there.
By the way, if you are on Goodreads, let’s connect!
8 thoughts on “Bravely Throwing Out a Piece of the Soul”
Hi there. If you like, take a look at my latest piece. There’s a book recommendation in it. See you.
Will do. Thanks!
I’m someone who doesn’t know you personally but am a regular Sarah Angleton groupie, I would suggest “Edward Trencom’s Nose” by Giles Milton. It is described on the cover as “A novel of history, dark intrigue, and Cheese”. I read it 4 or 5 years ago and giggled all the way to the end. The “Daily Express” reviewed it as “Rich, rather English and completely nutty”. I’d lend you my copy if you lived handy!
Oh, that sounds wonderful!
There was a lot of good reading this year. I go through books like a fish does water, so I won’t bombard you with every single one I think you might like, but here were some of my favs – the Huntress/the Alice Network – Kate Quinn. American Princess – S.M. Thorton. The Honey Bus – M. May. Educated – T. Westover. Where the Crawdads Sing – D. Owens. I Was Anastasia – A. Lawhon. Daisy Jones & the Six – T.J. Reid. Happy reading, you know where to find me if you want more! 🙂 Not on Goodreads, but I really should join one of these days.
Great list! I’ve read one of them and have a couple on my list already. And one I’d not heard anything about. So exciting!
I’m terrible about knowing which books to suggest to people, but I think you might like Dragon’s Teeth by Michael Crichton. It reminds me a bit of your Gentleman of Misfortune (although, fossils, not mummies). It’s fairly short for a Crichton book and moves quickly. I’ve also been trying to review everything I read this year, so you can always browse my Goodreads profile if you get desperate for reading ideas.
How is it possible there’s a Crichton book I didn’t know about?! He was a favorite of mine in my high school to college years. I’m excited to read him again!